This is in regard with Jean post on the issue of life jacket. But in life, things may not be as simple as it is. I perfectly understand why they choose not to wear as a ex-dragonboater myself. In high performance sports like dragonboat, you cannot have anything to hold you back. Life jacket is one thing that is really irritating and hinder your movement. I totally agree life jacket must be worn. Most of the race ended neck to neck(those without NJC joining) and very often you need a viewcam to decide the eventual winner. A 5% drop in performance means most likely you will lose the race. However, I must say the authorities must enforce it if not such accident will continue to happen.
As a super-safety conscious person myself, I would also be forced by the circumstances not to wear it. Being a rower, winning is everything. Can you imagine the anguish of them going through 4-5 times of grueling training per week and not to get anything back after the race?
Let me clear some of the misconception of the sport itself.
Miconception 1: Dragonboat is a exercise that use only arm power
Dragonboat uses legs to kick also and everytime after the race, I could feel my legs getting soft and jelly. Dragonboating uses lots of cardio too. That's why you see them often running around. It's a sport that requires you to have a great cardio and arm power to excel in it.
Misconception 2: Dragonboat sinks easily
I don't know what these people are really thinking about but dragonboat is really stable as it's base is wide enough. Even if you want to overturn it, it would need a lot of team effort to do it. For my three years as a rowers, I have not experience this myself. I only witness this during the dragonboat race when boats collide. That is only when boats collide.
Misconception 3: You need to be a swimmer to join this sport
Throughout my 3 years as a rower, there's so many non-swimmers I see participating in this sport. I can only keep my head barely afloat until my third year there. In other words, I mean my swimming sucks.
Misconception 4: Life jacket is a must
I remembered clearly that it is only halfway through my second year that SDBA enforce every rower to wear the jacket. It is not a must to wear jacket and wearing jacket makes rowing very uncomfy and prone to abrasion at the armpit area.
Once agin, I hope I have done nothing to offend Jean. Jean is my friend and I owe her many favor including getting her to put Reuben's Back Home music on her blog. I really appreciate her kindness for this.
I will be visiting them later in noon. I'm lost for words on what to say to them.
Monday, November 26, 2007
Clarify Misconception On Dragonboat
Posted by
Snam Profile
at
3:53 PM
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


6 comments:
A friend was talking about life jackets today with me over coffee.
A thought. Maybe think about using the inflatable lifejackets that the airlines use during competitions? since they're inflatable they're less likely to get in the way till you really need them.
But yeah, I understand the competition motivation. Anything it takes to win, even if it sometimes involves risk. Risk sometimes pays off, sometimes it don't.
Just be there dude. Words are superfluous, and we give what support we can.
I know the blog author is upset and distraught from the loss of a friend. No doubt it is painful. My condolences. I am not a dragonboat enthusiast, in fact far from interested in it. But I would like to highlight a point which the author raised.
Quote and unquote 'Being a rower, winning is everything. Can you imagine the anguish of them going through 4-5 times of grueling training per week and not to get anything back after the race?'.
I certainly hope this is not the mentality of the sportsmen who participate in competitions and events. No one should put their lives at risk just for that one moment of glory or for that moment of victory. Some may beg to differ on this comment on mine with this argument - we should live our lives to the fullest and do something great. Life is precious and fragile. Once you lost it, you won't get it back. Losing one competition ... well ... the feeling is sucky of course ... but if you have that one last breath in you ... you can live on to fight ... fight for the victory ... risking one's life and making the people worry about you ... and hurting them isn't at all glorious.
I certainly hope that there isn't a 'winning is everything' out there amongst sportsmen. Because it would be a sad thing. Whatever happened to the true spirit of sporting or competitions? Coz this isn't the true spirit of sportsmanship (regardless whether it's a singing competition or a sporting competition)
Anyway if there's something good that can happen out this tragedy is that no more precious lives will be lost this way.
'Being a rower, winning is everything. Can you imagine the anguish of them going through 4-5 times of grueling training per week and not to get anything back after the race?'
what's the point of winning if it compromise one's safety just to shave off that few seconds? Now the tragedy had happen, they can no longer take part any races.. I believe their friends and love ones who rather exchange that few seconds for their lives.
The coach must take the full responsibility too. He should not let them compromise such safety for the sake of winning.
do u really think tt the life jackets can make sure you float up under those kindof curcumstances?
i think it would make matters worse for those who went under the pontoon.
To the anonymous posted at 4:09 AM:
Get a life. Seriously, you will never understand if you are not in this sport.
Wearing a lifevest in that situation won't help you either. It will just make the whole thing worse. You couldn't swim under the pontoon. There could be more than 5 person died if they were wearing lifevests.
And please... Don't point all the faults to the captain. There is no one to blame in this situation. Dragon boat is about teamwork. I believe the decision for not wearing lifevests was also agreed by the team members. And in Cambodia race, nobody wears lifevests.
With regard of this incident, there is nothing to do with lifevest. It's the strong current and the pontoon. Do you know how dark was it swimming under the pontoon? You're lucky if you can find the way out. But I believe 5 of them couldn't.
I think you are too much affected by the Media!
To all,
I've talk to Jeremy's uncle and we come to the conclusion that life jacket is not going to help in this case. I also had friend almost had this experience during her scuba diving lesson.
Please read thenewPaper for the details. Will blog about this if I had the time.
Thanks for the comment. But I will still hold on to my words cos I can still feel it after 7 years without rowing. You will only understand when you are a rower.
I think Vandalin had given a very good suggestion but given the cost will it be worth it(economic wise)? I will talk to people in the sport itself for suggestion.
Post a Comment